When Analogies Mislead
There's a great summary over at
Photon Courier of a study that shows people can make analogies from the flimsiest resemblences. In the test scanario, subjects were inspired to find analogies between a hypothetical threat from one nation to another: and it was shockingly easy to get them to see either the Vietnam war or WWII as parallels.
Quite an insight into our teeny tiny minds.
Posted by: Attila at
10:51 PM
| Comments (6)
| Add Comment
Post contains 72 words, total size 1 kb.
1
This may explain the success of Michael Moore crockumentaries.
Posted by: Ciggy at May 18, 2005 07:46 AM (0B3lJ)
2
It certainly explains the m.o. of this Bush Administration...
Oh wait, the m.o. is "a lie told often enough becomes the truth."
Posted by: littlemrmahatma at May 18, 2005 07:52 AM (BZ0tI)
3
Somebody, in comments somewhere, suggested that the results may be somewhat artificial, in that the subjects were students--and have probably learned well to suck up to their professors, using whatever cues are available to indicate the desired answers...
Posted by: David Foster at May 18, 2005 09:50 AM (+N6Ef)
4
It's actually the core of the genius of the human mind that allows us to draw connections between disparate objects/concepts. Our massively parallel minds are finely tuned to seek connections.
Ask a programmer how hard it is to teach a computer to recognize a face. Yet as humans, we do it without thinking. It makes for some interesting dichotomies (like comment #1 and #2 on this post), but without this ability, we'd be little more than food processing machines.
Like everything else is with humans, take away the source of all the problems, and you take away what is most essentially human.
Posted by: a4g at May 18, 2005 03:33 PM (H8Yyz)
Posted by: Attila Girl at May 18, 2005 09:21 PM (x/EKm)
Posted by: remote at June 03, 2005 11:44 AM (Y7dVX)
Hide Comments
| Add Comment
Masonry
After Jane was
called a Mason by those who wish to discredit her, one of her readers pointed out that 1) there are lodges of people who call themselves Masons and yet are co-ed or all-female; these are not generally recognized by the majority as true Masons, and 2) there has been a mixed reaction to the Order of the Eastern Star, with British Masons a good deal more skeptical or negative than U.S. Lodges.
I have no first-hand knowledge of this issue, but my family's history is intertwined with Things Mason, so it might be appropriate to comment.
My grandfather was a Shriner and either a 32nd or 33rd degree Mason, depending upon whom one speaks to. Some cousins tell me they are skeptical about the 33rd degree version of the story; it's apparently very rare for this to be granted at all. Let's just say the exact ordinal is a little hazy, but he was way into it.
My grandmother, his wife, was a member of the Order of the Eastern Star, and I believe a female cousin on his side is as well: she appears to be even more gung ho about the Masonic culture than her husband is, though she holds the belief that females cannot be Masons.
My mother was a member of Job's Daughters, and her younger sister was in the Rainbow Girls.
When my mother took her first long trip away from home she was 16; she was traveling by bus. This would have been in 1952, ten years before I arrived on this planet. As my grandfather drove her to the bus station he told her that if she ever got in trouble or needed help in any way, she should look for someone with a Mason ring, and get help from him.
That is interesting to me: my grandfather was essentially telling my mother that there are some strange men you can trust. If I have a daughter would I ever tell her that she could always trust someone she met through, say, Twelve Step programs? No: there are a lot of crazy people in Twelve Step programs.
But I feel good that there is an organization out there that engenders that level of trust. I like the notion that once in a while there's a way to guess which people might be decent human beings.
At present my aunt wears my grandmother's Order of the Eastern Star ring. I like that. Someday I'll probably wear it myself. It's pretty, and it reminds me that underneath all my family's problems and neuroses, there is a thread of decency, a concern for Doing the Right Thing, at least most of the time. It's nice to think about that every now and again.
Posted by: Attila at
11:27 PM
| Comments (5)
| Add Comment
Post contains 462 words, total size 3 kb.
1
LMA,
Well put! As a 32nd Degree Scottish Rite Mason and York Rite Knight Templar, I can attest to the fact that we Masons are far from perfect as individuals (especially this one!), but at least TRY to hold up the ideals of service, fairness and generally ethical dealings with the world in our lives, regardless of whatever political, religious, ethnic, national, or class background we may have.
Posted by: Mikal at May 08, 2005 04:51 PM (N1Lj5)
2
BTW:
When I looked at the original context of the "Mason" slur, I understood it better.
Militant Islam, like all ideologies based on intolerance and envy, HATES Freemasonry because it brings together men of different religious, political, ethnic, national and class identities as individuals committed to common ethical goals. This subverts the divide-and-conquer strategy of resentment-based politics, so naturally they can't stand us, and use the "secret society" slur to whip up suspicion against us. (Actually, our "secret" rituals have been publically "exposed" for centuries; the true mysteries of Freemasonry lie in the ineffable experiences that brothers go through in the initiatory and lodge processes, as well as in our commitment to protecting each other's individual confidences, murder and treason excepted.)
For haters, paranoiacs, and politcal extremists, Freemasons have a very high International Bad Guy status. It's right behind that of -- you guessed it -- THE JOOOOOOS.
Posted by: Mikal at May 08, 2005 05:02 PM (N1Lj5)
3
Well, there's the Trilateral Commission
Posted by: Attila Girl at May 08, 2005 07:10 PM (FAdyB)
4
Funny how you find people occasionally with very similar backgrounds. My grandfather is a 33rd degree Mason with all the hooha that goes along with it. My father is a 32nd degree. Me, I'm a Catholic living in a generation that absolutely could care less about fraternal organizations after college and believes that by the time our children are in their 30's, there will be no more Elks, Moose, KofC, or Masons.
Posted by: Short time reader first time poster at May 09, 2005 07:35 AM (YeUTv)
5
No mooses? That would be sad.
Posted by: Attila Girl at May 09, 2005 09:23 AM (FAdyB)
Hide Comments
| Add Comment
31kb generated in CPU 0.2767, elapsed 0.35 seconds.
208 queries taking 0.3311 seconds, 441 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.